Wheel V Controller in the F1 game is a question often asked and debated in the sim racing community. In previous years controller racers have been able to compete closely with wheel racers.
However this distance may have widened due to the F1 games mechanics not being suited to the controller.
With F1 23 set for release the game will feature what Codemasters and EA have called Precision drive. Over recent years, controller racers have felt they have been a disadvantage.
In past F1 games controller racers were just as competitive as those racing with a wheel. The likes of controller geniuses such as Louis Welch have been able to keep with in good distance of top Esports drivers.
There are valid reasons on both sides and this article will explore the Wheel V Controller debate and which may appeal to you more.
Comparison between wheel and controller
Design wheel v controller
The design between controller and wheel are night and day. A controller is a simple handheld piece of equipment with buttons for controlling the car.
A wheel on the other hand is the sum of many parts. Usually a wheel requires a wheel base, pedals and a surface or construction to keep it in place.
The controller is more compact and lightweight, making it easier to hold for extended periods of time making it more comfortable to use.
They are also easier to set up and use than wheels, which often require additional software and calibration.
In contrast, using a wheel can be more tiring as it requires the player to sit in a specific position and use their arms and hands to control the wheel.
Features
Wheels are very versatile and there are multiple options to choose from. This can range from different formula style wheels, addition buttons, materials and more, the variety wide ranging.
Another advantage of using a wheel is that it allows for more customisation. Most wheels have programmable buttons that can be mapped to different functions in the game.
This means that players can set up their wheel to suit their individual preferences and playing style. They can also adjust the sensitivity and force feedback settings to optimise their performance.
A controller means you’re restricted to in options, a limited amount of buttons and much less ability to customise.
Realism wheel v controller
This can help the player to feel more immersed in the game and improve their driving skills. Additionally, a wheel provides more precise control over the car’s steering, acceleration, and braking, which is especially important in high-speed racing games like F1.
The force feedback feature of the wheel provides feedback on the car’s movements and road surface, allowing players to accelerate, brake, and shift gears just like in a real car. This makes the overall experience more enjoyable and engaging.
Although a controller may provide a rumble or vibration this doesn’t quite provide the authentic feel most sim racers will be looking for. This most definitely will be better mimicked through a wheel and pedals that provide such a feature
F1 23 Precision Drive FOR CONTROLLER
For the past few years, controller users in the F1 game have been left somewhat disappointed with their ability to race with the pad.
Many felt that the pad was somewhat unresponsive, cornering was not accurate and there would be delays in the rotation. Some still made good use of the pad finding techniques to counter the inadequacies however they felt something needed to be changed.
Enter F1 23 in what Codemasters and EA have now introduced what is called ‘Precision Drive’. This feature will be introduced in the latest incarnation of the game set to be released on June 2023.
The precision drive will be implemented to improve the controller experience. The developers aim to make the steering movements smoother, more accurate and the ability to correct the car.
Conclusion
So there you have it, a closer insight into the wheel v controller debate in F1.
Ultimately, the choice between a wheel and a controller comes down to personal preference and budget. While a wheel provides a more realistic experience, it can be expensive and may not be suitable for everyone. A controller, on the other hand, is more affordable and easier to use, but it may not provide the same level of immersion. In the end, it’s up to the individual to decide which option works best for them.
In conclusion, both wheels and controllers have their own advantages and disadvantages when it comes to playing F1 games. It ultimately comes down to personal preference and playing style. Players who prioritise realism and precision may prefer to use a wheel, while those who prioritise accessibility and comfort may prefer to use a controller.